On the nail, they stay pretty darn close, too. On two fingers, I used 3 coats by themselves, on the other fingers, I put two coats over Rimmel Black Satin.
The most different I could get them to look was this:
DVD is slightly more pigmented and possibly just a tiny bit more blue, but I don't think one needs to have both of these. I'll keep DVD since Sally and I go way back. If I were buying new, though, I'd be tempted by Jesse's Girl, since it's cheaper and like the new bottles they have.
Speaking of the bottles, in the old line, Jesse's Girl Confetti was a blue and fuchsia bar glitter; a kind swapper on MUA just sent me a bottle of it as an extra. Way to be confusing, Jesse's Girl.
Back to the new bottles, I noticed something the other day about the display, only because one of my Rite Aids had put it next to the Wet 'n' Wild FastDry display.
Same sunglasses, same lips: coincidence? I think not.