1. Manic Panic Blood Thirsty (3 coats)
2. Manic Panic Hellfire (4)
3. Manic Panic Heavy Metal (3)
4. Manic Panic Immortal (2)
5. Fright Night unnamed orange (3)
6. Fright Night unnamed black/orange bar glitter (3)
7. Fright Night Sinister (2)
8. Fright Night Toxic (2)
9. Fright Night Toxic (2) [I bought these in two different years and thought they were different enough to keep both, but now I'm thinking they're really, really close]
10. Fright Night Poison (2)
11. Fright Night Poison (2) [same as with the two Toxics]
12. Fright Night Bloodshed
13. Fright Night VooDoo (2)
14. Fright Night unnamed blue (2)
15. Sally Girl unnamed glow in the dark (3)
16. Ulta Ghoul's Night Out (3)
17. Wet 'n' wild Fantasy Makers Glow in the Dark (3)
18. China Glaze Ghoulish Glow (3)
19. Maybelline Glow in the Dark Glow Over (3)
20. Diamond Cosmetics Gloworm Green (3)
Bottles 1 through 4:
5 through 10:
11 through 14:
15 through 20:
Of course I had to try to capture the glow in the dark ones glowing. The Maybelline is the clear winner here—too bad they don't make it anymore. I guess back then either the glow in the dark stuff was cheaper so they added more or maybe there was a chemical they could use back then that's since been found to cause cancer if drunk in large volumes.
Last photo above shows the Maybelline glowing when the others have faded out almost completely. That's some powerful stuff.